Reflections from the Camp Fire: A shared responsibility

Camp_Fire_Large.jpgWalking the blackened earth where a wildfire has passed through, there’s much to learn. We can see the growing scope of the hazard, how a brush fire explodes into a catastrophe, the challenges firefighters face, and the choices people make that can save or threaten lives and property.

In Paradise, California, after the historic Camp Fire, the sights were familiar to veterans of past fires but startling to visitors seeing a major wildfire scene for the first time: a lone structure still standing untouched in a wasteland of charred foundations or one ruin fallen amid a block of intact homes.

I was one of a small group that toured the town in January as part of a post-event effort to unify stakeholders—including representatives of government, the fire service, the insurance industry, and research organizations—that serve Californians at risk of wildfire. We visited the site to deepen our understanding of how such a disaster unfolds.

Here are some of the sights and their implications that struck me:

  • A wildfire can cripple a community’s defenses against it. When a neighborhood starts to burn, collapsing structures can rupture their own water lines. Several broken pipes per structure, multiplied up and down a street, can quickly drop pressure to hydrants and impede firefighting efforts throughout the community.
  • The evacuation plans of even the best-prepared communities aren’t foolproof. Emergency notifications can reach every available channel, and police can reverse traffic flow to speed evacuees to safety, but fallen trees or power lines can still halt the exodus until crews clear the route.
  • Strong winds make a fire’s spread not only faster but less predictable. Adjoining properties downwind can ignite just from radiant heat, while airborne embers can travel far and start spot fires wherever they land on flammable material, creating random pockets of destruction.
  • The terrifying speed of a blaze such as the Camp Fire isn’t random; it’s a mix of wind, steep slopes, dense and dry fuels, and difficult road access to the area that’s burning. In its first 12 hours, the Camp Fire traveled nearly 15 miles downwind and burned more than 55,000 acres, or about 76 acres a minute.

Seeking order in chaos

Any large wildfire is likely to produce some inexplicable outcomes. Properties adhering to the latest codes and guidelines can be destroyed, while others that seem to have the entire risk deck stacked against them may come out unscathed. For every instance, there’s a reason waiting to be understood. But on the whole, preparations and precautions that are well entrenched in vulnerable areas do help.

The National Fire Protection Association’s (NFPA) Firewise USA®program provides extensive education and advice to help wildfire-exposed populations protect themselves and their properties. In the Camp Fire and others, how much worse might the outcomes have been without these guidelines? And the Ready, Set, Go! campaign of the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE)—a program managed by the International Association of Fire Chiefs (IAFC)—also helped residents begin prompt, life-saving evacuations.

The ongoing study of wildfire events can help further confirm what works and what doesn’t, reveal areas for improvement, and point to questions that haven’t been considered before. Such continual learning is needed to stay ahead of the rising threat of wildfire as a year-round phenomenon. As Governor Gavin Newsom made clear in his executive order issued on January 8, this will require tapping a wide array of resources in the public and private sectors.

Choosing wisely

When actively managing  exposure to wildfire risk, it’s important to understand the tools that can help guide decisions. Science can hold up a mirror to the choices homeowners and communities make about individual properties, overall development strategies, and public safety as well as what gets built, how and where it’s constructed, and the resources devoted to protection from wildfire and other threats.

The choices become more complex as expensive housing markets in fast-growing local economies drive development deeper into the wildland-urban interface (WUI), where the wildfire battle is most intense. These are areas where homes and businesses abut dry, mountainous, fuel-rich environments that often have seasonal weather patterns that can heighten extreme fire behavior. There may be hard choices to make—but also opportunities for state and local governments, communities, first responders, and the private sector to join in responsible, sustainable solutions for the people who live as neighbors with nature.

ISO Fire Suppression Rating Schedule

Our Fire Suppression Rating Schedule (FSRS) is free to chiefs and other fire officials. It's a manual containing the criteria ISO uses in reviewing the fire prevention and fire suppression capabilities of individual communities or fire protection areas. To recieve a copy of the FSRS, contact our National Processing Center at 1-800-444-4554 and select Option 2.

H2O and ISO

Water supply and distribution systems are important factors in determining a community’s ISO Public Protection Classification (PPC®). We provide complimentary educational training and seminars to water providers and associations throughout the country. Contact Anthony Zampella, national water resources manager, at 908-821-7689 or e-mail azampella@iso.com for more information.

ISO and Verisk websites

  • isomitigation.com
    ISO Mitigation Online for community officials; learn all about ISO’s PPC® program and BCEGS® program